|
Sunday, August 15, 2004
Arthur and Anne
|
 |
FAMILY: UC Irvine
biologists Anne Calof, left, and husband Arthur Lander hold daughter
Sophia at their Laguna Beach home. Their first child died from a
genetic defect that sent the parents searching for the cause.
EUGENE GARCIA, THE ORANGE COUNTY REGISTER
|
MORE PHOTOS |
|
By GARY ROBBINS
The Orange County Register
LAGUNA BEACH
Sophia's got a sweet tooth. It's a warm day and the toddler wants "eye keem."
Her mother Anne brightens. "She's saying ice
cream." Sophia's dad Arthur catches on and brags a bit. "She's 19
months old and knows 200 words. We wrote them down."
The list lies on their kitchen table, an
affirmation of love and pride. You expect this from parents. The
surprise is that there's a little girl sitting here, jabbering away.
A ghost brought immense pain to this home four
years ago, the kind that underscores the fragility of life and makes
some couples forsake ever having another baby.
As they eased into middle age, Arthur Lander and
his wife Anne Calof were betrayed by biology. Their first child,
Isabel, died a month after she was born, claimed by an unknown gene
that randomly disrupts and destroys and, in rare instances, kills.
Arthur and Anne asked, "Why us?" They also wanted to know: "Which gene?"
The ghost had struck parents who could strike back.
Both are developmental biologists at the
University of California, Irvine, where they run comfortably cluttered
labs that are abuzz with the business of figuring out how genes and
cells control life.
Arthur and Anne joined the hunt for the one gene
in 30,000 or so that sometimes goes awry, causing the birth defect that
killed Isabel.
"We wanted to honor our daughter's memory," Anne said.
In the quiet ways of science, the mutant gene
has been unmasked, a discovery hastened by one of Arthur's hunches and
refined by Anne's study of mice.
But that's not paramount on this warm day. With
a fresh sense of what it means to be human and humane, they had a
second child. Her name is Sophia Rose Lander. And right now, she wants
eye-keem.
COME TOGETHER
Arthur always wanted kids. Anne - not so much.
She was focused on building a career in science,
a field that can be subtly hostile to women. Only five years ago, the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology admitted that it had a history of
marginalizing female researchers.
The issue began to surface at MIT in the early
1990s, when Arthur was on the faculty. Anne was looking for a permanent
faculty position. The market in greater Boston was tight. She refused
to compromise.
"I didn't want a girl job - a non-tenure track
job that became disposable when the financial situation in a department
changed ...I wanted security and the chance to build my own research
program and train scientists."
The remark is pure Anne. She is a
get-to-the-point workaholic who walks fast and talks faster, often
piling several ideas into one long sentence.
Opportunity awaited at the University of Iowa,
which had an opening for a developmental biologist. Anne took the job,
which meant she and Arthur would spend the first years of their
marriage 1,000 miles apart.
Arthur regularly flew to Iowa, where he filled Anne's refrigerator with fish stew and
other dishes he prepared, a skill he picked up out of necessity. As a
kid, he cracked wise once too often about his mother's cooking, leading
her to snap: learn to cook for yourself. He did, later turning his
touch with food into one of the most popular courses at UCI, "Science
in the Kitchen."
The visits weren't enough. Arthur and Anne wanted to be together.
Arthur thought, "Should I go to Iowa? Should Anne come to MIT?"
He recalled this in the way he says most things,
with the sort of calm, unhurried demeanor of announcers on National
Public Radio.
The solution to their problem was UCI, which was undergoing a boom in the biological sciences. Arthur
studies how cells communicate, especially as it applies to cancer and
birth defects. Anne explores the nervous system, focusing on how genes
get various portions of the brain grow to their appropriate size.
Irvine needed scholars in both areas. The campus
offered them jobs. In 1995, UCI became their home. They occupy offices
on the same floor of McGaugh Hall, in offices less than 100 feet apart,
sitting at desks that, at times, each seem on the verge of collapse
from the weight papers and reports.
Arthur, a physician-trained-scientist, thought, "Finally, we can think about having a family."
Anne, the daughter of an Air Force pilot,
remained ambivalent until she came to feel that "having a child would
make our relationship fuller and deeper."
It took awhile. But in mid-1999, when she was in her early 40s, Anne became pregnant with Isabel. Expectations soared:
"I'm obviously going to have a child that goes
to Yale like Arthur did or Reed College like I did and get a Ph.D, and
if this child doesn't get all As, I'm going to be disappointed."
Things seem good. .
TROUBLED TIMES
A sick feeling washed over Arthur and Anne
during the ninth week of the pregnancy. A grainy black-and-white
ultrasound showed that the inch-long embryo that would become Isabel
had a shiny bubble that extended from her neck all the way down her
back.
"It's a sort of non-specific bad sign," Anne
said. "It's frequently, but not always, correlated with some
developmental disorder."
There are no tests for most disorders of this type, which fed their anxiety.
The bubble eventually disappeared. Their
anxieties did not. For reasons that weren't yet clear, Isabel was
growing too slowly. She ended up being born a month early -- Feb. 28,
2000 -- and weighed less than three pounds. She also needed immediate
surgery at UCI Medical Center in Orange to fix a problem in her
gastro-intestinal tract.
The bad news piled up.
A new ultra-sound revealed that Isabel had
grossly undersized kidneys. If she lived, she would need dialysis and
probably a transplant.
"I think we just cried for about an hour," said Anne.
The root cause of Isabel's problems emerged a
few days later when tape and tubing were moved away from her tiny pink
face. A geneticist noticed signature signs of Cornelia de Lange
Syndrome, which can cause such things as down-turned lips, a short,
upturned nose, lowered ears and small stature and head size.
Some people with the birth defect also have
shortened or missing limbs, heart defects and eye problems. But all
suffer from mental retardation, which is typically moderate to severe.
And the defect usually makes it hard to verbalize. Some sufferers never
talk. Many are in chronic pain.
Anne and Arthur were crushed with sadness, whip-sawed by uncertainty.
"We were trying to figure out if this diagnosis was a death sentence, or just a sentence of terrible," said Anne.
They weren't alone in their sorrow, something Arthur came to understand more deeply:
"There's knowing this stuff is out there. And
then there's realizing other people share the same kind of experiences.
You don't really learn that last part unless you go through it
yourself."
A BATTLE JOINED
Tap, tap, tap.
Sitting in Anne's hospital room, Arthur worked
his laptop, searching the Internet for anything he could learn about a
syndrome that afflicts about one in every 10,000 newborns. It was
exasperating. There are several thousand kinds of birth defects. Most
are like Cornelia de Lange Syndrome in the sense that they're obscure,
with no clear cause.
He pressed on. Arthur's not the type to give up.
While studying at Yale about 20 years ago, he auditioned for parts in
plays, one of his passions. He had little success; directors didn't
like his Brooklyn accent. Arthur responded by producing two musicals,
which he also wrote and directed.
If one door is closed, try another. This is how Arthur thinks.
Soon, a door opened. He learned that there was a
geneticist at Childrens Hospital of Philadelphia who was trying to find
the mutant gene that causes the syndrome. Ian Krantz, it turned out,
was the only scientist in the country whose entire laboratory had this
mission.
Arthur introduced himself by e-mail, beginning a
collaboration that took on deeper meaning on March 30, 2000. That day,
Isabel died without ever having left the hospital.
By then, Arthur and Anne had decided to join the
search for the mutant gene. Such a discovery could lead to a way to
confirm or diagnose a disease that is hard to study because it
typically does not run in families.
Science is not a solitary enterprise. It's a
collaboration in which people contribute in many ways. Arthur and
Anne's involvement reflects that.
They became science advisors to the Cornelia de
Lange Syndrome Foundation, a family support organization. Anne joined
the board of directors. And they got directly involved with Krantz,
providing him with a sample of Isabel's blood to see if he could tease
out DNA to look for genetic clues. They opened their personal medical
records up for review, and plunged into the real heart of research --
swapping ideas in the dense argot of biology. Arthur got and sent
e-mails with phrases like, "We have linkage to 5p13.2 with marker
D5S426 ..."
Anne underwent an epiphany:
"I used to think basic research was somehow
better than applied research, but now I've changed my mind," she wrote
in Current Biology. "Now it seems entirely worthwhile to focus one's
scientific curiosity on problems whose solutions will have a direct
impact on our lives and the lives of our children."
WHERE, OH WHERE?
A typo, of sorts, causes many diseases, including this defect.
Our 30,000-plus genes are composed of four
chemicals that are known by the letters A, T, G and C. The letters are
arranged differently in each gene, determining its function.
A change in any one of these letters -- a
chemical typo -- can produce a mutation that's harmful, even deadly.
And locating the mutation can be like trying to find a single
misspelled word in "War and Peace."
Krantz was looking for the gene, and the misspelling, when Arthur and Anne came into his life.
The situation wasn't hopeless; they knew they
were looking for a gene that can cause widespread problems, narrowing
the search some. But Krantz spent significant time looking at pieces of
genes on the wrong chromosome.
That's the biological equivalent of trying to find someone in Irvine when you should be looking in Miami.
Early on, he was groping about and the National
Institutes of Health knew it, rejecting Krantz's first two requests for
$1.5 million to broaden the search.
"This is part of the problem with rare genetic
syndromes," Arthur said "NIH will give you money if you convince them
you'll have the answer in five years."
Arthur helped re-write the grant proposal, which
reached NIH at a time when the sequencing of the human and mouse
genomes was ripping along, helping expose the potential cause of myriad
diseases, including birth defects. This time, the grant was approved.
By 2002, things were improving. And not just in the lab.
Arthur and Anne decided to take another chance
on having a family. Love delivered on Oct. 2, 2002, when Sophia entered
the world, healthy.
Having Isabel "reinforced our desire to have
children," Anne said. "It sounds sappy and hard to understand but you
learn so many things from your child. You realize someone doesn't have
to be perfect for your to love them."
YOU'VE GOT E-MAIL
It's often a hunch that moves science forward, an inner voice that says, "What about this?"
Arthur got that feeling one afternoon last fall
while using his iMac to comb a mouse data base for genes that might
cause far reaching birth defects. Mice are very similar to humans
genetically, making them ideal for study.
He wrote "IDN3" on a piece of paper and circled
it. The gene's make-up seemed capable of altering many tissues and
organs, like the birth defect.
"You should definitely pay attention to this one," Arthur told Krantz by e-mail, playing that hunch.
Krantz was following the same path. The e-mail
simply accelerated the search a bit. He wrote back on Dec. 11, saying,
"We're on the cusp of discovery ... Let me break the suspense, the gene
turns out to be IDN3."
The breakthrough was confirmed two weeks later.
Two weeks later, the breakthrough was confirmed. A genetic scourge had
been exposed three days before Christmas.
Arthur was elated, but downplayed his role: "I'm
sitting here playing back seat driver. He's in the lab, sequencing
stuff ...I was right, but I said five other things, too."
The contribution was deeper than that. Earlier
this year, Arthur and Anne performed a series of experiments on mice
that graphically illustrated that IDN3 is the kind of gene that causes
this birth defect, a finding that gave weight to the scientific paper
Krantz submitted to Nature Genetics. The journal recently published the
paper, announcing the breakthrough.
Scientifically, Anne and Arthur have moved on.
They're trying to create a strain of mice that have the syndrome, an
essential step toward opening the disease to much broader study.
Emotionally, the couple also are in a different place, something that was evident last Christmas.
Arthur is Jewish. Anne is Christian. They never used to make a big deal of the holiday. This time, they bought a tree.
"We set (the tree) up on the patio and strung
lights and ornaments while Sophia toddled around, pulling things off
and getting tangled up in the lights," Arthur says. "She laughed and
cooed when we illuminated the tree for the first time. It felt like
family should feel."
CONTACT US: (714) 796-7970 or grobbins@ocregister.com
|